Criticalmath - Peer Review Management

Submit Your Review to the CriticalMath Administrator

Questions? Comments?
Tell us what you think about CriticalMath!

Need a free manuscript management solution? Holding a conference? Are you a journal editor? Do you publish a blog? Criticalmath is a simple, user-friendly manuscript management system. Our website will deliver manuscripts to your email, help you keep track of peer reviewers, and maintain important statistics -- for Free! More...

Welcome to the Criticalmath Manuscript Management System. You can use this form to instantly deliver your review to the CriticalMath Administrator. If your personal identification does not appear below, please enter your Manuscript ID and Reviewer ID, which you will find in your reviewer request email. If you have any questions as you proceed, please contact us at brain@criticalmath.com. Required fields are denoted by a "*".

Identification
Select Publication
Reviewer ID*
Manuscript ID*(i.e., 20060523-123)
Your identification is kept strictly confidential.
Evaluation
Accept Manuscript
1. Publish in its present form with only routine copyediting.
2. Publish contingent on minor changes; further external review not necessary.
Ask Author to Revise and Resubmit Manuscript
3. Likely to be published after minor revision.
4. May be publishable after substantial revision.
Reject Manuscript
5. Requires fundamental revision to be considered for publication.
6. Not publishable even with fundamental revision.
7. Inappropriate for the CriticalMath Administrator. More appropriate for another journal. (Please indicate this journal in your comments below.)

Please estimate the likelihood that this author can succeed in revising this manuscript so that it is publishable in the CriticalMath Administrator by entering a percentage in the blank. *
%

Upload Anonymous Review File
Prepare your anonymous review in any standard word processing program (Microsoft Word, etc), save, then upload your document by clicking Browse, then selecting the file name.*

Optional Note for Editors

Would you be willing to review this manuscript again?
Yes No